Critical thinking MCQs for MDCAT

Critical thinking is chapter 1 of 6 in the PMDC MDCAT Logical Reasoning syllabus. Below are 3 sample MCQs with answers and explanations. The full bank has 79 questions on this chapter.

Sample questions

Q1"We should appoint Dr Kamal as head of the research lab, because he has published more papers than any other applicant." Which assumption underlies this recommendation?

  1. AThe number of papers published shows how well someone would run a lab
  2. BDr Kamal has worked at the lab before
  3. CThe other applicants have never published anything
  4. DResearch papers are expensive to publish
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: A. The number of papers published shows how well someone would run a lab

The only reason given for appointing Dr Kamal is that he has published the most papers. That supports the recommendation only if the number of papers shows how well someone would run a lab. This is the hidden assumption.

  • B is wrong: Previous work at the lab is never mentioned, so the argument does not rely on it.
  • C is wrong: The argument says he has more papers, not that the others have none.
  • D is wrong: The cost of publishing papers is irrelevant to choosing the head of the lab.

Q2"Ali must be a good doctor because he graduated from a famous medical college." Which assumption does this argument depend on?

  1. AAli studied harder than his classmates
  2. BFamous colleges charge high fees
  3. CGraduates of famous medical colleges are good doctors
  4. DGood doctors always work in famous hospitals
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: C. Graduates of famous medical colleges are good doctors

An assumption is an unstated idea that the argument needs to be true. The argument goes from 'Ali graduated from a famous college' straight to 'Ali is a good doctor'. That jump only works if graduates of famous medical colleges are good doctors, so this is the hidden assumption.

  • A is wrong: The argument never mentions how hard Ali studied, so it does not depend on this.
  • B is wrong: Fees have nothing to do with whether Ali is a good doctor. The argument does not rely on cost.
  • D is wrong: Where good doctors work is not part of the reasoning. The argument is about Ali's college, not hospitals.

Q3"You cannot trust Dr. Kamal's research on smoking; he is a rude man." What is wrong with this reasoning?

  1. AIt attacks the person instead of the evidence
  2. BIt generalises from too few examples
  3. CIt offers only two choices when more exist
  4. DIt assumes that what is popular must be true
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: A. It attacks the person instead of the evidence

The speaker rejects the research because of Dr. Kamal's manners, not because of any problem with the evidence. Attacking the person instead of the argument is called an ad hominem fallacy. Whether he is rude says nothing about whether his research on smoking is sound.

  • B is wrong: That describes a hasty generalisation, which draws a broad rule from a few cases. No cases are counted here.
  • C is wrong: That describes a false dilemma, which offers only two choices. No choices are offered here.
  • D is wrong: That describes an appeal to popularity. Nothing in the statement mentions what most people believe.

Topics in these questions: Assumptions, Logical fallacies.

More Logical Reasoning chapters